Evaluating Social Media's Impact on American Democracy

In recent years, the role of social media in American politics has come under intense scrutiny. Proponents argue that social media has democratized information dissemination, allowing underrepresented voices to be heard and providing an accessible platform for civic engagement. Critics, however, contend that social media platforms amplify misinformation, contribute to political polarization, and allow foreign interference in U.S. elections.

Using the perspectives outlined above, construct a well-reasoned argument that evaluates the extent to which social media serves as a tool for democratic engagement versus a source of misinformation and division. Support your position with relevant evidence and examples from historical and contemporary contexts.