Evaluating Environmental Argument on Plastic Pollution

Medium Argument Evaluation Evaluate Reasoning

The following argument is presented by an environmental advocacy group regarding plastic use:

"The increasing levels of plastic pollution in our oceans are a direct consequence of the excessive packaging practices employed by food manufacturers. Therefore, if food manufacturers switch to biodegradable packaging, the decrease in plastic waste will significantly improve marine life health and restore the ocean ecosystem. Thus, it is imperative for consumers to demand alternatives to plastic packaging to spur manufacturers into action."

The argument assumes that all food manufacturers are equally responsible for plastic pollution.

The argument overlooks the role of consumers in contributing to plastic pollution.

The argument fails to provide evidence that biodegradable packaging is effective for all types of food products.

The argument presupposes that a switch to alternative packaging will be cost-effective for manufacturers.

The argument assumes that the health of marine life is solely dependent on reductions in plastic waste.

Hint

Submitted9.1K

Correct7.4K

% Correct81%