Identifying Flaws in Recycling Program Argument

Hard Critical Reasoning Identifying Flaws

During the annual Town Hall meeting, the mayor reported that since the introduction of a new recycling program, the town has seen a significant increase in the amount of waste being recycled. Consequently, the mayor claimed that the new recycling program must be the reason for the increased recycling rates. However, some residents pointed out that last year's extreme weather conditions, which reduced waste production, might have also contributed to the increase in recycling rates.

Based on the mayor's argument, which of the following identifies a flaw in the reasoning?

The mayor does not consider other significant factors that could have influenced the increase in recycling rates, such as changes in waste management policies.

The claim of increased recycling rates is based solely on anecdotal evidence from community members without statistical support.

The mayor assumes that an increase in the amount of waste recycled directly correlates with the efficacy of the recycling program without analyzing other variables.

The mayor's conclusion overlooks the possibility that individual residents are recycling more out of personal choice, independent of the program.

Hint

Submitted5.6K

Correct3.3K

% Correct59%