In recent years, the city council has proposed a new initiative aimed at enhancing public transportation to reduce traffic congestion and decrease pollution levels. The initiative involves investing in more bus routes, increasing subway service frequency, and implementing bike-sharing programs. Proponents argue that this initiative will make public transport more accessible and encourage residents to use it instead of their cars. Opponents, however, claim that the funds for such improvements should instead be used to repair existing roads and infrastructure, which they argue would have a more immediate benefit to the community.

Write an essay in which you evaluate the clarity of the position taken by both proponents and opponents of the initiative. Discuss how effectively each side communicates their argument and the implications of their positions on public policy.