Crime Rate Assertion Flaw

Very Hard Flaw In The Reasoning Identify Logical Flaw

In a discussion about crime rates in a metropolitan area, a criminologist asserted, "Crime has increased in this city since a significant number of new residents have moved in. Therefore, we can conclude that these new residents are responsible for the rise in crime rates." This statement has drawn mixed reactions.

A fellow researcher pointed out that these new residents might be moving to the city for jobs, which could reduce crime due to increased economic opportunities. However, the criminologist stood firm in the original stance, suggesting that the evidence correlating new residents to crime increase is sufficient to establish causation.

The criminologist assumes that correlation between new residents and crime rates indicates direct causation.

The fellow researcher ignores any evidence that suggests crime rates might increase due to other factors.

The criminologist fails to provide specific data on crime rates prior to the influx of new residents.

The statement overlooks the potential effects of socio-economic changes caused by new residents.

The criminologist uses anecdotal evidence from non-scientific sources to support the claim.

Hint

Submitted5.3K

Correct2.6K

% Correct49%