Evaluating Assumptions in Social Media Arguments

Very Hard Argument Evaluation Evaluate Reasoning

In a discussion about the effects of social media on interpersonal relationships, a psychologist presents the following argument:

"Social media creates an illusion of connection among individuals, leading to less face-to-face interaction. As a result, people develop poorer communication skills and experience increased loneliness, which undermines mental health. Thus, to improve mental well-being in society, we should encourage less use of social media."

Another author, however, challenges this perspective, claiming, "Social media can actually enhance interpersonal connections by allowing individuals to communicate across vast distances and maintain relationships that might otherwise fade. Rather than blaming social media for loneliness, we should consider how individuals choose to engage with it. Many people use social media to facilitate their in-person relationships, not replace them."

The psychologist's argument assumes that all social media interactions are inherently inferior to face-to-face interactions.

The author who defends social media relies on anecdotal evidence rather than empirical data.

The psychologist provides clear causal evidence linking social media use to poor communication skills.

The debate implies that those who use social media more frequently are more likely to feel lonely.

The psychologist argues that all forms of social media lead to enhanced communication abilities.

Hint

Submitted10.0K

Correct7.7K

% Correct77%