Evaluating Urban Development Arguments

Medium Critical Reasoning Evaluating Arguments

In a discussion about urban development, a city council member stated, "Investing in infrastructure improvements will lead to an increase in tourism, which is vital for the local economy." Another council member countered, "But many cities that have invested significantly in their infrastructure have not seen a corresponding increase in tourism. Therefore, funding infrastructure improvements may not guarantee economic growth through tourism."

Which of the following, if true, would most seriously weaken the second council member's argument?

Cities that improved infrastructure simultaneously launched marketing campaigns that successfully targeted tourists.

Tourism statistics can vary widely based on seasonal changes and economic conditions.

Studies have shown that tourists are attracted to cities with modern amenities and well-maintained public facilities.

A significant number of tourists prefer to visit cities with a rich historical background rather than modern developments.

Hint

Submitted4.1K

Correct3.9K

% Correct95%