Film Adaptation Critiques

In the following passage, two critics discuss a recent film adaptation of a classic novel. Critic A argues that the film successfully captures the essence of the novel through its visual storytelling. Critic B, however, contends that the film’s changes dilute the original message of the novel. Consider their arguments in relation to how different media can convey themes and narratives.

Critic A states, 'The stunning visuals and poignant score in the film evoke the same emotional depth found in the novel. It brings to life the landscape that shapes the characters’ experiences.' In contrast, Critic B argues, 'While the visuals are captivating, the loss of the protagonist’s inner monologues undermines the complexity of the character. The novel's intricate themes require the reader’s contemplation rather than a viewer's passive experience.'

Based on the criticisms presented, what can be inferred about their views on how adaptations can interpret source material?