Identifying Flaws in Traffic Safety Argument

Hard Flaw In The Reasoning Identify Logical Flaw

In a recent debate about traffic safety measures, a local politician stated, "Since the implementation of speed bumps in our neighborhood, there has been a noticeable decrease in accidents involving pedestrians. Therefore, speed bumps must be the reason for the declining accident rates."

Which of the following best identifies a flaw in the politician's reasoning?

The politician ignores other possible factors that could have contributed to the decrease in pedestrian accidents.

The statement lacks statistical evidence to support the claim that speed bumps directly caused the accident decline.

The politician makes an assumption that all neighborhoods with speed bumps experience the same level of traffic issues.

The argument relies on anecdotal evidence rather than scientific data.

The politician fails to consider that speed bumps may increase the likelihood of other types of accidents.

Hint

Submitted11.3K

Correct7.5K

% Correct66%