Identifying Flaw in Traffic Safety Argument

Easy Flaw In The Reasoning Identify Logical Flaw

During a community meeting, a city official argued, "Since we decreased the speed limit in our neighborhoods, traffic accidents have dropped significantly. Therefore, lowering speed limits is the best solution for improving road safety." This reasoning is flawed because:

The official fails to consider whether other factors may have contributed to the decrease in accidents.

Lowering speed limits might actually lead to an increase in traffic congestion.

Many residents may not comply with the new speed limits.

Traffic accidents are inevitable in urban areas, regardless of speed limits.

The official did not survey the opinions of all residents before making a claim.

Hint

Submitted8.7K

Correct6.6K

% Correct75%