In the context of liability-driven investing (LDI), a fixed income portfolio manager is evaluating a new indexing strategy to better match the duration and cash flow requirements of their client’s liabilities. The liabilities pertain to a defined benefit pension plan where the expected payouts are fixed and occur at specific future dates.
The manager is considering the effectiveness of a broad-based bond index versus a more bespoke bond index tailored specifically to the characteristics of the pension plan’s liabilities. Understanding that the primary goal is aligning the cash flows of the investment portfolio with the timing and amounts of the liabilities, the question revolves around the benefits and drawbacks of these two indexing approaches.
Which of the following statements most accurately reflects the appropriate use of these indexing strategies within a liability-driven investment framework?