Understanding Tone and Attitude in Climate Discussion
In a recent university seminar, a professor discussed the impact of climate change on marine biodiversity. During the seminar, he stated:
"It's alarming to consider how rapidly our oceans are changing. Every study I’ve reviewed indicates a significant decline in fish populations, with some species facing extinction. This is not just a scientific concern; it's an issue that affects local economies, food security, and even cultural traditions tied to fishing communities. We must act swiftly and decisively, or we risk losing these irreplaceable resources forever. It's time for us to take our responsibilities seriously and address these challenges head-on."
Following this, a student remarked:
"While I appreciate your concerns, it seems to me that some proposals for immediate action might not consider the complexities of our economic systems. Yes, fish populations are declining, but we must also think about the livelihoods of the fishermen who depend on this industry. Any initiative should balance environmental urgency with economic realities, or we may end up harming those we aim to help."
Note: This question has been adapted from its original format to accommodate a reading-based version. In the official TOEFL exam, speaking and listening sections require verbal responses and audio prompts, which are not represented here. Please note that this adaptation may not fully reflect the nature or difficulty of the official exam. The audio feature for these sections will be available soon.
Select all that apply: