Flaw in Reasoning: Correlation vs. Causation

Very Hard Flaw In The Reasoning Identify Logical Flaw

During a recent panel discussion on education reform, one expert stated, "Standardized tests are effective measures of student intelligence. Since schools that have implemented rigorous testing have shown improved academic performance, it follows that standardized testing is the best way to enhance educational outcomes."

Another panelist responded, "The evidence presented is flawed because increased testing does not necessarily equate to a genuine understanding of the material. Many students may perform well on standardized tests yet fail to truly grasp the concepts being assessed."

The first expert's reasoning is fundamentally flawed because it:

rests on the assumption that correlation implies causation.

overlooks alternative explanations for the improved performance.

fails to consider the emotional impact of standardized testing on students.

dismisses the role of teachers in preparing students for tests.

relies on anecdotal evidence rather than statistical data.

Hint

Submitted3.7K

Correct2.8K

% Correct74%